View Thread
 Print Thread
Children of Green Knowe Rewatch Thursday 22nd August 7.45pm (BST)
OneSparePart
Puppies are not just for Christmas...
Silflay hraka, u embleer rah!
 
AnneArthur

OneSparePart wrote:

I didn't think God rest ye merry gentlemen was so old a carol


I think that's in their church. But, says Wikipedia, an early version is found in a Bodleian manuscript of the 1650s.
 
OneSparePart

M1795537OCVirn wrote:

OneSparePart wrote:

I didn't think God rest ye merry gentlemen was so old a carol



Apparently dates from 1650. Is that old enough for you?

I think it's cos it's so inextricably linked to Dickens and Victorian times.
Silflay hraka, u embleer rah!
 
AnneArthur
The tune of Ding Dong Merrily is medieval, I think.
 
AnneArthur
That was lovely! Thanks for that.
 
M1795537OCVirn
It's going to be so bleak when he has to go back to school - for both of them.
"You're not sulking, I hope?"
 
OneSparePart

AnneArthur wrote:

The tune of Ding Dong Merrily is medieval, I think.

Well it would be with those hey nonny nonny noes in it.
Silflay hraka, u embleer rah!
 
AnneArthur
It's a pity there aren't any more. There's a film of the second book, with Maggie Smith as the granny I think - I'm sure I've seen it on TV - but I don't think there are any more series.
 
AnneArthur

M1795537OCVirn wrote:

It's going to be so bleak when he has to go back to school - for both of them.


But they're going to look forward to the next holiday so much!
 
OneSparePart

M1795537OCVirn wrote:

It's going to be so bleak when he has to go back to school - for both of them.

There's still time for the house to burn down....
Silflay hraka, u embleer rah!
 
M1795537OCVirn

AnneArthur wrote:

It's a pity there aren't any more. There's a film of the second book, with Maggie Smith as the granny I think - I'm sure I've seen it on TV - but I don't think there are any more series.


THere's a film with Patricia Routledge available. Do you want to watch it next week?
"You're not sulking, I hope?"
 
M1795537OCVirn

OneSparePart wrote:

M1795537OCVirn wrote:

It's going to be so bleak when he has to go back to school - for both of them.

There's still time for the house to burn down....


Heartless beast!
"You're not sulking, I hope?"
 
AnneArthur

M1795537OCVirn wrote:

OneSparePart wrote:

M1795537OCVirn wrote:

It's going to be so bleak when he has to go back to school - for both of them.

There's still time for the house to burn down....


Heartless beast!


I burns down in the second book, in the eighteenth century (I think) - but it is rebuilt.
 
AnneArthur
I would be quite happy to - although I don't think it could be as good as that.
 
OneSparePart

M1795537OCVirn wrote:

AnneArthur wrote:

It's a pity there aren't any more. There's a film of the second book, with Maggie Smith as the granny I think - I'm sure I've seen it on TV - but I don't think there are any more series.


THere's a film with Patricia Routledge available. Do you want to watch it next week?

What about eps 5 and 6?
Just had a look. 4 episodes! What a (lack of) ending!
Edited by OneSparePart on 22-08-2024 19:57
Silflay hraka, u embleer rah!
 
OneSparePart

M1795537OCVirn wrote:

OneSparePart wrote:

M1795537OCVirn wrote:

It's going to be so bleak when he has to go back to school - for both of them.

There's still time for the house to burn down....


Heartless beast!

My middle names
Silflay hraka, u embleer rah!
 
M1795537OCVirn

OneSparePart wrote:

AnneArthur wrote:

The tune of Ding Dong Merrily is medieval, I think.

Well it would be with those hey nonny nonny noes in it.


There aren't any in any version I've sung. Only gloooooooooorias. Also, the words of Ding Dong are Victorian, althougn the tune is older..
"You're not sulking, I hope?"
 
AnneArthur

M1795537OCVirn wrote:

OneSparePart wrote:

AnneArthur wrote:

The tune of Ding Dong Merrily is medieval, I think.

Well it would be with those hey nonny nonny noes in it.


There aren't any in any version I've sung. Only gloooooooooorias. Also, the words of Ding Dong are Victorian, althougn the tune is older..


Yes, that's why I said the tune. The words are merely cod-medieval.
 
AnneArthur

OneSparePart wrote:

M1795537OCVirn wrote:

AnneArthur wrote:

It's a pity there aren't any more. There's a film of the second book, with Maggie Smith as the granny I think - I'm sure I've seen it on TV - but I don't think there are any more series.


THere's a film with Patricia Routledge available. Do you want to watch it next week?

What about eps 5 and 6?
Just had a look. 4 episodes! What a (lack of) ending!


It's really about the atmosphere, and the growing friendship with the children - I liked the ending, where they are all coming and listening to the story too.
 
M1795537OCVirn

AnneArthur wrote:

I would be quite happy to - although I don't think it could be as good as that.



Don't want to spoil the original for you, but it might be interesting to see how they did a different version?
"You're not sulking, I hope?"
 
M1795537OCVirn

AnneArthur wrote:

M1795537OCVirn wrote:

OneSparePart wrote:

AnneArthur wrote:

The tune of Ding Dong Merrily is medieval, I think.

Well it would be with those hey nonny nonny noes in it.


There aren't any in any version I've sung. Only gloooooooooorias. Also, the words of Ding Dong are Victorian, althougn the tune is older..


Yes, that's why I said the tune. The words are merely cod-medieval.


Darling, I wasn't arguing with you. Just trying to teach the Heartless Beast a thing or two.
"You're not sulking, I hope?"
 
AnneArthur

M1795537OCVirn wrote:

AnneArthur wrote:

M1795537OCVirn wrote:

OneSparePart wrote:

AnneArthur wrote:

The tune of Ding Dong Merrily is medieval, I think.

Well it would be with those hey nonny nonny noes in it.


There aren't any in any version I've sung. Only gloooooooooorias. Also, the words of Ding Dong are Victorian, althougn the tune is older..


Yes, that's why I said the tune. The words are merely cod-medieval.


Darling, I wasn't arguing with you. Just trying to teach the Heartless Beast a thing or two.


Sorry - I know you weren't! That came off as snippier than I intended.

And yes, let's do another version. The film of the second book (if we want to see it) is called From Time to Time.
 
AnneArthur
Anyway, I need to go. Lovely to see you both - and lovely finally to get to watch this. I've been meaning to for years.
 
OneSparePart

M1795537OCVirn wrote:

AnneArthur wrote:

M1795537OCVirn wrote:

OneSparePart wrote:

AnneArthur wrote:

The tune of Ding Dong Merrily is medieval, I think.

Well it would be with those hey nonny nonny noes in it.


There aren't any in any version I've sung. Only gloooooooooorias. Also, the words of Ding Dong are Victorian, althougn the tune is older..


Yes, that's why I said the tune. The words are merely cod-medieval.


Darling, I wasn't arguing with you. Just trying to teach the Heartless Beast a thing or two.

Do not take my middle names in vain! I have definitely sung a version with the nonnies in but then I do come from a very backward part of the country.
Silflay hraka, u embleer rah!
 
OneSparePart
See you next week for more green noahs.
Silflay hraka, u embleer rah!
 
M1795537OCVirn
The COGK film is 1 hour 27 mins. Is that OK?
any ideas where we can stream Time to Time?
"You're not sulking, I hope?"
 
M1795537OCVirn
Thanks for the suggestion, and the company. See you next time.
"You're not sulking, I hope?"
 
OneSparePart
https://youtu.be/H6DN41UjO2g?si=ZB_5G..._5_NvajhhJ

Is this the film you mean?
Silflay hraka, u embleer rah!
 
M1795537OCVirn


I think that's the one Anne mentioned, yes. Maybe I should post both links on the next thread and see what happens!
"You're not sulking, I hope?"
 
Jump to Forum